Monday, August 05, 2013

A review of More than Magnets : Exploring the Wonders of Science in Preschool and Kindergarten

More than Magnets : Exploring the Wonders of Science in Preschool and Kindergarten by Sally Moomaw and Brenda Hieronymus, published by Redleaf Press in 1997.


A review by the NAEYC Early Childhood Science Interest Forum.

Explore simple machines with your children, enhance the learning opportunities at your science table, improve your conversations with science focused open-ended questions. More than Magnets, is an excellent resource for classroom teachers of children 3 to 5. With 117 activities ranging from physical to life, and chemical sciences, there is a rich array of opportunities to enhance science learning throughout the pre-K classroom and curriculum. The introduction lays out the authors’ approach, “Whole Science”, offering a Piagetian view of child development and explaining what young children are able to understand scientifically. Throughout the book the authors work to build the readers understanding of the science concepts being explored and what young children might learn about them.

Activities are organized in Chapters that include Science Displays, Machines and Pendulums, Science at the Sensory Table, Art, Music, Cooking, and Gross Motor. Some activities stand alone, such as “A Spring Tradition: Varieties of Seeds.” In the Science Displays chapter, this activity provides an overview of what children might learn about seeds and the plants that grow from them. It lists the materials needed and the sequence for implementation. It also describes what to look for in the children’s response, a few questions to extend thinking, and Modifications that incorporate literacy and documentation. Finally it suggests “Integrated Curriculum Activities”. Some of these suggestions extend the learning into other areas of the curriculum while others extend science learning.

In contrast, some of the activities are sequenced to deepen children’s science understanding over time. An example is in the Machines and Pendulums chapter. Six activities take children from an introduction of balls and ramps to an exploration of the effect of ramp texture on the speed of vehicles. Each activity follows the same format and includes detailed descriptions of the materials needed and a “Sequence for Implementation.” There is much guidance to help teachers enhance science learning. Starting with information about the science itself and what children might learn about it. There are also typical child responses gathered from a field test of the activities. One of the strengths of these instructions is the excellent questions for the teachers to use when promoting children’s scientific thinking. “Modifications” and “Integrated Curriculum Activities” suggest additional ways to enrich the science learning. Finally, “Helpful Hints” address ways to make the activity safe for the children as well as ways to adjust for different developmental levels.

We would recommend that users of this guide allow children some time to explore the materials in a more open-ended way at times, allowing them to experiment and trying out their own ideas. For example, the ramps sequence is carefully constructed to focus children on particular concepts such as momentum or friction. While there is value to this structure, children would also benefit from time to more openly explore in order to become familiar with the materials. The interests and ideas revealed in their exploration might suggest a different sequence for the activities. In this case the inquiry would be driven by the children and thus enrich their ability to consider the hows and whys of their experience, see patterns, and make meaning. 

Written before the New Generation Science Standards (NGSS), direct connections are not made to the learning continuum, however the experiences cover a wide range of content in the physical, life, and chemical sciences. The science concepts introduced easily connect to later learning as presented in NGSS. Most importantly, the authors present an inquiry-based approach to learning involving three key elements of the inquiry process - hands-on explorations, documentation, and discussion. 

Early Childhood Science and Engineering Resource Reviews

What is best practice in early childhood science teaching? What should young children be learning about science? How can we best support teachers as they work to build a science rich curriculum in their classrooms? Our interest forum was created to provide an ongoing discussion of these important questions. Over the years many books and resources in other formats have been published that attempt to provide answers to these questions. Some are more successful than others. We are going to use this space to post reviews of resources and hopefully at the same time communicate a set of ideas about inquiry-based science teaching and appropriate content for young children. Please share your thoughts about these reviews, experiences you have had using these resources, and any suggestions for books you would like us to review in the future. 

The reviews will be posted as new posts.